Back to Eve
The Tort Report

The premier publication for plaintiff law

Back to Eve
The Tort Report

The premier publication for plaintiff law

Newsletter

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.

Subscribe

California's New AI Law Could Price Small Firms Out of AI

Lawyers must disclose AI use on every filing it touches. Small firms will pay the most to do it.

By Sheryl Nance-Nash — 5 min read

Illustration of a clipped stack of legal documents with a highlighted line that turns into circuit traces.

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.

On Jan. 1, every California lawyer who uses AI on a court filing has to tell the judge. Nobody has told the lawyers how.

Nikoo Berenji has been trying to find out. Her Beverly Hills firm, Berenji Divorce & Family Law Group, spent months getting ready for Senate Bill 574, the first state law to regulate how attorneys use generative AI. It bought the tools, tested the platforms and rewrote its handbooks. Then it reached the disclosure rule.

"We're struggling with the disclosure requirement," said Berenji, the firm's managing attorney and director of operations. "The law is extremely vague about what a firm actually has to do to comply. We understand that we need to disclose AI-assisted drafting or work that goes into a pleading, but nobody knows exactly how to do that."

She wonders whether a general disclaimer on every filing, saying AI may have been used, would be enough. "Or does the disclosure need to be specific, spelling out which parts were AI-assisted and which weren't?" she said. "We really need more guidance from the State Bar or some other authority so firms can figure out how to comply in a consistent way."

Disclosure is only one piece of the law. SB 574 also restricts what a lawyer can type into an AI tool, makes one attorney personally answerable for every citation in a filing, and can put the firm on the hook when a citation goes wrong. Small plaintiff firms have leaned on AI to keep up with bigger opponents, and for them the law arrives as a new cost.

She did the homework and still doesn't know how to comply

Berenji's firm started early. It bought AI tools for its entire staff, chosen to keep client information confidential, she said. Earlier this year it piloted several legal AI platforms, had staff run the same tasks on each one, and held focus groups to compare where each fell short before committing.

"We've also talked with our team about the security measures they need to take to protect client confidentiality, and we've added new SOPs to both our staff and attorney handbooks that spell out clearly what they can and can't do with AI," she said.

Even the right tools may not settle the confidentiality question. The statute's test is who can see what a lawyer types in, so a firm has to confirm that each vendor's terms restrict that access.

The protected list looks like a PI case file

Gov. Gavin Newsom signed SB 574 on Sept. 30. Its author, state Sen. Tom Umberg, explained the bill in a statement when it passed the Senate. "As AI becomes more common in the legal system, we need clear guardrails to protect clients' confidentiality and ensure that real people, not algorithms, are making legal decisions," he said.

Lawyers can still use AI for research and drafting. They can't delegate "the practice of law" to it, a phrase the statute doesn't define. The law also sets four duties:

  • Confidentiality. Lawyers can't enter confidential, personal identifying or other nonpublic information into an AI system unless access to that information is restricted to the attorney and people the attorney has authorized, who must be bound to protect it. The definition covers medical and psychiatric information, financial information, dates of birth, and the addresses and phone numbers of parties and witnesses. That's most of an injury firm's case file.
  • Verification. Lawyers must take reasonable steps to check what AI produces and correct anything wrong or invented.
  • Citations. The attorney responsible for a filing must personally verify every citation in it, whether AI supplied the citation or a first-year associate did. A miss is grounds for sanctions, and the firm can be held responsible along with the lawyer.
  • Disclosure. Lawyers must disclose AI use to the court for all documents they submit, and must consider disclosing it when AI helps create content for the public. The statute sets no form and no threshold for how much AI use counts.

Arbitrators are covered too. They can't delegate any part of their decision-making to AI.

Headshot of Brian Morgan-Heit.
Brian Morgan-Heit

The real bill is lawyer time

Brian Morgan-Heit, co-founder of Cedar Employment Law, an employee-side firm in Southern California, has no quarrel with what the law is trying to do.

"The benefit is accountability," he said. "Lawyers should never outsource their professional judgment, compromise client confidences, or submit legal authorities they haven't verified."

The limit on arbitrators matters to his clients too. "For employees required to arbitrate their claims, preserving independent human judgment is particularly important," he said.

His worry is who pays. "The impact is potentially substantial, particularly for solo practitioners and smaller firms without dedicated technology or compliance departments," he said. "The greatest expense may not be purchasing compliant technology, but the attorney time necessary to supervise and verify its work."

The stakes are highest on the plaintiff side, he said. "We routinely represent individuals against corporations defended by national law firms with substantially greater resources. AI has the potential to level that playing field. It allows smaller firms to organize substantial evidence, conduct preliminary research, and operate more efficiently without the overhead of a large legal team."

If using AI responsibly becomes too expensive, large firms will absorb the cost and small ones will struggle. "Ultimately, that disadvantages the individuals seeking representation," he said.

He also expects the loosely worded disclosure rule to push firms into heavy compliance routines that do nothing for the client.

Morgan-Heit, whose firm uses Eve, is keeping his own preparation plain. He recommends a short AI-use policy, a hard look at each vendor's confidentiality protections, staff training, and mandatory attorney review before AI-assisted work reaches a client, opposing counsel or the court.

"The goal should be practical safeguards, not unnecessary bureaucracy," he said.

The outcome he fears most is a law that leaves the best tools to the firms that can afford the overhead.

"My central concern is that we do not inadvertently create a system where only the largest, wealthiest firms can afford to use the most effective legal technology," he said. "AI should reduce the cost of delivering competent legal representation, not reduce the standard of competence itself."

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.