Back to Eve
The Tort Report

The premier publication for plaintiff law

Back to Eve
The Tort Report

The premier publication for plaintiff law

Newsletter

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.

Subscribe
Newsletter

A Reddit thread caught what inspectors missed

Sixteen million people rode it. The pattern was on Reddit the whole time.

By Adam Ramirez — 5 min read

Pamela Guillen went to Six Flags Magic Mountain on July 5 for her daughter’s 16th birthday and left in an ambulance. She was 39 and healthy. She rode X2, walked off, collapsed, and spent most of a month in the hospital after emergency surgery to stop the bleeding in her brain. Six days later, Naomi Greer-Wilkinson, 25, collapsed at the same exit with the same injury. She is on a ventilator and has not spoken since.

Six Flags closed the ride that night. In September, after a wrongful death settlement and three new lawsuits, it closed X2 for good while insisting the coaster “consistently passed a multitude of safety tests.”

Then the lawyers started counting. Gary Dordick says more than 100 people have come to his firm with brain injuries from X2 in the past two years. Two riders are dead.

Sixteen million people rode it. A hundred injuries, one machine, twenty years, and until two women collapsed in the same week, every one of them was a "fluke."

Aerial view of a large red and gray steel roller coaster with loops at a theme park beside dry hills.

X2 at Six Flags Magic Mountain in Valencia, Calif., on Sept. 23, the day three riders sued over brain injuries. Six days later the park retired it. (AP Photo/Jae C. Hong)

The park had the data. The riders had Reddit.

Who regulates a roller coaster? Not the federal government. In 1981 the theme park industry got Congress to carve fixed rides out of the Consumer Product Safety Commission’s reach, so the CPSC cannot set foot in the park to investigate X2. Ed Markey has been trying to close the roller coaster loophole since 1999.

That leaves the states, and California is one of the strict ones. It inspects rides every year and makes parks keep five years of injury records, which means the numbers were sitting in a file somewhere in Valencia the whole time.

Christopher Hawley was 22 when he rode X2 in June 2022. He died the next day. In his family’s wrongful death case, an expert testified that Six Flags’ own records showed at least 70 complaints of head or neck injuries on the ride in the three years before his death. The answer was in the defendant’s paper, the way it usually is (Meredith Hinton found hers over lunch). Getting it took the Hawleys’ lawyers years, because Six Flags fought every records request until a judge set a sanctions hearing.

The regulars had worked it out on their own. On Reddit, X2 riders traded "unspoken rules" for getting through it without getting hurt, and one wore a soft helmet. Dordick’s three September suits say the park knew about Guillen’s brain bleed six days before Greer-Wilkinson boarded.

Nobody whose job it was to add those injuries up ever did. A Reddit thread and a plaintiffs’ firm with a discovery motion did it for them. Dordick took only the riders who had seen a doctor before they called a lawyer. That is how a hundred flukes become one defect.

A trial date closed a ride that passed every test.

Dordick’s cases are the new ones. The case that moved the park was older. After Hawley died in 2022, Six Flags tested X2 again, and the ride passed, as it had in 2008 and 2018. In court, the park said his brain bleed came from a preexisting condition.

His parents, Anne and William Hawley, spent the next three years fighting that. Trial was set for September 8 of this year. On August 26 the case settled. Five weeks later Six Flags retired X2, saying the coaster had passed every safety test and the park was closing it anyway because “we believe it’s the right thing to do.”

A standard that says yes when the right answer is no was built to measure the wrong thing. This one measured g-forces against a number the industry wrote for itself, and nobody was measuring the exit platform.

You've heard this defense: the standard was met, the inspection passed, the regulator signed off. Here the regulator signed off twice. What moved the park was a sanctions hearing, a trial date, and a discovery fight that turned up 70 complaints the inspections never did.

Closing X2 is not an admission. Six Flags has not conceded the ride hurt anyone, and it's defending more than a hundred claims, with at least one trial set for 2027.

But the next time a defense expert hands you a passed inspection, remember that X2 had three.

One more thing

I have spent my whole life trying to like roller coasters. Growing up, anything that spun or dropped sent me to a bench while my friends went around again. I would sit there, green, promising myself the next one would be different.

It never is. On a family trip to the Emirates last year we rode Formula Rossa at Ferrari World, the fastest roller coaster on earth. It launches you from zero to 149 miles per hour in under five seconds, and they hand you goggles because at that speed the desert air hurts. I survived it, groggy and drowsy from the motion sickness pills I took to get through it. It was a hack, and it worked.

Two men in red racing team shirts react on a roller coaster, one smiling and one grimacing.

I live a few minutes from LEGOLAND, a theme park built for people who are four feet tall. For years I drove past the gates with a longboard on the roof, headed for the break down the street, and never gave the place a thought. My daughter is 4 now. I have a season pass. I am in there a lot.

A young girl hugs a life-size toy brick figure dressed in a red racing outfit at a theme park.

Her favorite ride is Unikitty's Disco Drop. It lifts you a couple of stories and lets you down in little hops while a cartoon cat grins at you from the top. Every rider but one is in preschool. Last time I sat there holding my daughter's hand, felt the old queasiness arrive right on schedule, and kept my face brave for her the whole way down.

She wanted to go again. I wanted the bench.

Riders dangle from a spinning drop tower ride beside a colorful Unikitty's Disco Drop sign.

In the summer I lobby hard for the water park. The lazy river and the wave pool are my speed, and given a real choice I would skip the park and take her boogie boarding, where the only thing that drops you is the Pacific.

The Pacific has never passed a safety test. It has never claimed to either.

~ Adam

PS: Want to be featured in The Tort Report? Reply with the verdict you still can't believe you won.

Quote of the week

"Had Six Flags conducted appropriate testing, it would have no choice but to admit that the ride forces were dangerous and were the cause of the serious injuries."

— Timothy Loranger, partner at Wisner Baum, who led the trial team for Christopher Hawley's family.

A smiling man in a blue suit and floral tie stands before a window with a city skyline behind him.

Past Issues

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.

The Tort Report

One email a week on the verdicts, the AI, and the money reshaping plaintiff law. Read by 500 leading plaintiff firms.